Engine Knocking At Idle—What Could Be Wrong?

We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

If your engine is knocking at idle, it’s not a good sign. This could pose several problems if you try to drive the vehicle down the road. However, what could be causing the engine to knock? We have researched on your behalf to help answer this question!

Here are the possible culprits as to why your engine is knocking at idle:

  • Bad spark plugs
  • Poor fuel quality
  • Bad knock sensor
  • Bad fuel/air mixture
  • Lousy timing belt or pulleys
  • Worn bearings
  • Loose bolts
  • Bad pistons
  • Worn valve guides

We understand that may seem like an intimidating list, but not to worry! In this article, we will discuss each of these culprits in detail to help you diagnose the problem with your engine. In addition, we will take a look at the costs of fixing a knocking engine, so read on!

Man with his broken car checking engine on the highway roadside at sunset, Engine Knocking At Idle—What Could Be Wrong?

Engine Knocking At Idle—What Could Be Wrong?

In an ideal world, your vehicle’s engine should run smoothly and quietly at idle. However, this is not always the case. If you find yourself in a situation where your engine is knocking at idle, it’s best to take the necessary steps to investigate what could be wrong with it.

As stated above, there are many reasons why your vehicle could suddenly begin knocking at idle, which vary from simple problems like bad spark plugs to more severe issues such as a faulty timing belt or worn bearings!

To help you narrow down what is causing your engine problem, we have categorized the different problems that could be causing it.

Young handsome Caucasian man had a car breakdown and calling roadside assistance.

Bad Spark Plugs

The first thing to check when you get an engine knocking at idle is the spark plugs. If the spark plugs are covered with buildup or soaked in fuel, they can cause your engine to run roughly. If this is the case, you will want to replace the spark plugs as soon as possible.

Poor Fuel Quality

The next problem that could be causing your engine to knock at idle is poor fuel quality. Again, you may not realize it, but if you are using fuel that is anything other than what your vehicle calls for, it can cause issues with your vehicle’s operation.

For example, let’s say you use the cheapest gasoline available to save money at the pump, and you drive a car that calls for premium gasoline. Unfortunately, using cheap gas will decrease the octane level of the fuel, which can cause damage to your engine.

So, if you are experiencing issues with your engine knocking at idle, you should look at the brand of gasoline you are using.

Bad Knock Sensor

Next on this list is the knock sensor. The knock sensor is responsible for listening to any abnormal engine noises. This is one reason why if you hear an abnormal noise coming from your engine, it’s best to get it looked at right away.

While most sensors do not pose any problems, sometimes they can fail, which will cause issues with your vehicle’s fuel economy and operation. When this happens, you will want to replace your knock sensor immediately for the sake of your vehicle’s performance.

Bad Fuel/Air Mixture

The next possible cause for engines knocking at idle is a lousy fuel and air mixture. This happens when there is not enough air in the system to support all of the fuel burning in your engine. Since your car requires a specific ratio of air to fuel, when this ratio is off, it can cause issues with your car’s performance.

Bad Timing Belt or Pulleys

Another potential issue that could be causing your engine to knock at idle is a broken timing belt or pulley. If the timing belt on your engine fails, it will throw off the entire system’s timing which can cause your engine to misfire.

The same issue is true for pulleys on the timing belt or other belts driven by the motor. If one of these belts is broken, it will throw off the timing of the entire system, which can cause your car to knock at idle.

Worn Bearings

If you have a slipping fan belt or bad bearings on your engine, it can cause your car to knock at idle. This is because if the bearing is worn, they will not allow the pulleys and belts to rotate freely, which can cause a jerky ride for the passengers in your car.

Loose Bolts

Lastly, if your vehicle’s bolts are loose, it can cause problems with its operation. Loose engine components such as the head gasket or oil pan will allow extra movement in your car, which can result in knocking noises when you drive at low speeds.

If you suspect that any of these issues may be causing the problem check your engine for any loose bolts or metal shavings. If you find these, tighten the offending bolt accordingly to ensure that your engine is operating at its peak performance.

Bad Pistons

Another possible cause for your car’s engine knocking at idle is bad pistons. The piston’s job is to compress the air and fuel mixture before it explodes in the cylinder. If this process does not occur correctly, you could experience issues with your vehicle’s performance while idling.

Worn Valve Guides

Worn valve guides could potentially cause engine knocking. The job of the valve guide is to keep your valves in place while they are in operation.

If these guides are worn, they will not be able to hold your valves in place, which can cause them to move around when your car is idling, causing it to make a knocking noise.

Is it bad if your engine starts knocking?

While many issues can lead to your engine making knocking noises, none of them are good. This is because the root cause for engines making these abnormal sounds are always related to poor performance.

So, if you experience an engine knock while idling or at any other time, it’s best to get it looked at as soon as possible. This is because depending on the severity of the issue, it can lead to more severe engine issues in the future.

The most common sign that your engine might be knocking is an abnormal noise when the vehicle is idle. Other signs of this problem are an engine that doesn’t feel right while driving, excessive oil consumption, or feeling like the car has decreased power. It’s also not uncommon for a knocking engine to have warning lights appear on the dashboard, indicating the issue.

How do you fix a knocking sound in an engine?

While it might be tempting to fix your engine’s knocking noise yourself, it is essential to understand that this isn’t the best course of action. This is because many mechanics will recommend that you have your engine rebuilt or replaced if they hear an abnormal noise while idling.

The first thing a mechanic will do if they hear your engine knocking is to determine what the exact cause for this issue is. Once they know the root of the problem, they recommend that your entire engine be replaced if it is damaged beyond repair.

Replacing an engine isn’t cheap, but it’s one of the only ways to guarantee that all abnormal noises are gone from your vehicle. However, if you are not prepared to spend the money on your engine replacement, a minor repair may be in order.

If your mechanic does determine that there is nothing wrong with your entire engine and that it only needs a few parts replaced, they will likely use a used part instead of a new one. This is because a used part will be just as good as a new one and can save you up to 50% of the cost.

Man calling someone for help with his broken car

Will thicker oil stop engine knocking?

Switching to thicker engine oil can indeed stop your car’s engine from knocking. This is because thicker oil has more lubrication, so it won’t be as hard for the pistons to compress the air and fuel mixture within the cylinders. Keep in mind that thicker engine oil isn’t a cure but will help slow down the issue until you get to a mechanic.

How much does it cost to fix a knocking engine?

The prices can vary depending on what exactly is wrong with the engine. The costs can range from $500 to $1,000 and up.

The labor rate for this could range from $50 to $80 per hour. Keep in mind that several hours may be needed when diagnosing the cause of the engine knock.

Hands of car mechanic in auto repair service.

How long can you drive with a knocking engine?

Driving with an engine that is knocking isn’t recommended. Because the root cause of the issue is poor performance, this will continue to happen while driving. This can lead to more damage occurring and even your vehicle overheating.

In addition, if the engine completely fails while you are driving in the city or on the highway, you are increasing the risk of being in an accident. If your engine is experiencing knocking, then pull over to a safe area and turn on your hazards. Then call a mechanic, and they can bring a tow truck to get your vehicle to their shop.

Final Thoughts

Man with his broken car checking engine on the highway roadside at sunset, Engine Knocking At Idle—What Could Be Wrong?

Overall, there are several possible reasons as to why your engine is knocking. However, if you notice that this is happening, you should get to a certified mechanic as soon as possible. They will then diagnose the issue and give you options on the following steps to take.

If you like this article, then you should also read these ones:

Smoke Coming From Exhaust—Here’s What Could Be Wrong

10 Engine Misfire Symptoms Every Driver Should Know

Why Do Cars Need Oil? [And What Happens If You Don’t Change Oil]

Leave a Reply